China secures its fringes by force. Australia should do it by invitation

But where will today’s five-year-old go as tomorrow’s climate change refugee? The governments of the Pacific island nations have a suggestion. They are asking for visa-free travel to Australia and New Zealand.

The group put it to Australia’s Penny Wong at a meeting of the foreign affairs ministers of the Pacific Island Forum on Friday. There’s “a strong desire for visa-free travel within the PIF member countries,” Fiji’s Deputy Prime Minister Biman Prasad said last week.

“The ministers also were concerned about how we have talked about regional integration for many years, yet there are a lot of barriers that exist with respect to visa-free travel to Australia-New Zealand.”

Australia is the great power of the Pacific Family nations, a continent-sized lifeboat for drowning populations. Would Australia support European Union-style visa-free travel for the region, creating a Pacific Union, the ABC’s Sabra Lane asked Penny Wong last week?

“Obviously that would be a transformative approach to the region,” replied Wong, “but there is a lot of work to do on how that would look.”

Loading

Translating this, Australian National University development economist Stephen Howes says: “Australia isn’t going to give the Pacific visa-free access,” but it is attempting to make “a huge step forward”.

Meaning? The Albanese government campaigned on a promise to create a new visa to allow permanent settlement in Australia specifically for Pacific islanders. There were to be 3000 of these Pacific Engagement Visas granted each year, with a work requirement attached. Australia already operates various temporary visa schemes for Pacific workers, but the PEVs would be the first to allow permanent settlement, and reserved only for people of the Pacific.

Quite apart from the humanitarian case, Howes points out the strategic value for Australia: “This is happening now because of China. This is something China can’t offer and Australia can. It’s people to people, it’s hearts and minds, it’s Pacific Family,” says the director of ANU’s Development Policy Centre.

China’s government has a big advantage over Australia in winning the loyalty of foreign leaders – bribes. We know from opposition members in the Solomons, for example, that Chinese officials offered bagfuls of cash to MPs in return for their support.

Loading

But Australia’s advantage trumps it. Beijing can offer bribes to Pacific leaders, but Australia can offer a future to Pacific peoples. In democratic nations like those of the Pacific, the people’s will triumphs over a corrupt leader’s personal agenda. And consider the way Beijing seeks to secure its South China Sea perimeter – by bullying the nations of South East Asia. By contrast, Australia has the opportunity to secure its Pacific perimeter by invitation.

The Lowy Institute’s director of research Herve Lemahieu says: “The best way you combat an encroaching Chinese sphere of influence in the Pacific is to combat it with a durable sphere of integration. It’ll have to be done in increments – the EU wasn’t done in one step.”

Lemahieu says that Australia currently is stuck in an unending game of “whack-a-mole” in the Pacific as it defends against Chinese advances “oscillating between the development lens and the security lens – the way out is to use the integration lens”.

Pacific island leaders are enthusiastic about the Pacific Engagement Visa, although they’d like the initial 3000 quota to be enlarged over time. But the risk now is that it doesn’t happen at all.

The snag? The Coalition. While it supports the PEV itself, the Coalition is opposed to the means of allocating the 3000 annual visas. It objects to the government’s plan to decide recipients on the basis of an annual lottery or random ballot.

New Zealand and the US use a lottery for similar schemes, and for the same reason – to use points or any other targeted system would contribute to brain drain from Pacific states. As Fiji’s Prasad has said: “Any other approach used by Australia would raise suspicion in the region.”

Australia can improve its future by improving the Pacific’s. Without the Coalition’s support, the government is looking to the Senate crossbench for some sanity.

Peter Hartcher is political and international editor.